How Products Get Picked for an Online Store

How Products Get Picked for an Online Store

Post

19

A funnel that filters products by marketplace rules, origin, shipping and fit.

This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.

The 2-minute Version

✔

Picking a product starts with the marketplace’s own rules, and those rules include safety laws, like the federal ban on selling recalled products.

✔

Every marketplace bans counterfeit goods, TikTok Shop also bans gray market items, and Walmart says sellers have to own what they sell and have the rights to sell any branded product.

✔

Walmart requires a product ID on every item and checks it against the database of GS1, the organization behind the barcodes on store products.

✔

Size, weight and how easily something breaks affect shipping, since a carrier like UPS can charge for the space a box takes up and some items count as hazardous materials.

✔

We buy wholesale and no longer do retail arbitrage (buying from store shelves to resell), and we test each product with a small first order and keep reordering only what sells with a healthy margin.

Before a product gets bought for an online store, it has to pass a few tests, and the first one is the marketplace’s own rulebook.

Test 1: The Marketplace’s Rules

Every marketplace keeps a list of products it won’t allow, and most keep a second list of products that need approval first.

Walmart’s prohibited products policy exists, in Walmart’s words, “to ensure a safe and trustworthy shopping experience for everyone,” and it makes sellers responsible for following local, state and federal laws. Its overview links to a separate policy page for dozens of product types, from alcohol and firearms to recalled products and weapons. Another group of categories needs Walmart’s pre-approval before a seller can offer them, and Walmart’s examples include books, fragrances, luxury brands and software.

eBay restricts some categories and bans others completely, and its rules apply to “all selling formats on eBay, including listing and eBay Live events.” Its list includes an alcohol policy, a counterfeit item policy, a hazardous materials policy and a product safety policy. Walmart and eBay both say a violation can lead to anything from a removed listing up to a suspended account.

TikTok Shop bans some products outright and lets sellers list others only after they qualify, as How TikTok Shop Turns Short Videos Into Orders explains. Etsy has its own prohibited items list on top of its Creativity Standards, as What Etsy Lets You Sell and What It Doesn’t lays out, and Amazon requires approval in some categories and for some brands, which Why Amazon Got Harder for New Sellers goes through.

Product Safety: Recalls and Children’s Products

Safety laws show up in marketplace rules too, and 2 of them come up often.

Recalled products. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, or CPSC, says “it is illegal to sell any recalled product.” Its advice for online sellers is to “Check cpsc.gov/recalls before listing your product for sale.”

Walmart’s policy reads, “Products that have been recalled are prohibited from sale on Walmart Marketplace,” and Walmart asks sellers to tell it about a recall within 24 hours of learning about it. TikTok Shop, eBay and Etsy bar recalled items as well, and eBay tells sellers to “check the manufacturer’s website and official recall sites for recall notices.”

Children’s products. The CPSC defines a children’s product as one “designed or intended primarily for children 12 years of age or younger.” When a product like that is covered by a children’s product safety rule, the domestic manufacturer or importer has to certify that it complies in a written Children’s Product Certificate, or CPC, based on “test results from a third-party, CPSC-accepted laboratory.”

Walmart lets sellers list children’s products only when each product is accompanied by a valid CPC, and eBay’s product safety policy asks every seller to put clear safety information, like labels and warnings, in the item description. For any product meant for kids, part of the check is whether that certificate exists and who issued it.

Test 2: Where It Came From

Every marketplace bans counterfeit goods, which Walmart describes as “inauthentic items intended to appear or sold as authentic.” Some go further, and TikTok bans gray market items, meaning “items sold outside of authorized distribution channels.” In plain words, a gray market item may be real, but it reached the seller through a route the brand didn’t approve.

Walmart says sellers must own the items they sell and have the licensing rights to sell any branded product. Amazon tells sellers to get authentic branded products from a legitimate source, like a wholesale supplier or manufacturer, and its reselling guide says to “Verify the authenticity and quality of products before selling them” and to keep records “such as purchase orders and invoices.” Some brands also give sellers a brand authorization letter, which Amazon calls “a letter directly from a brand that authorizes you to sell their products.”

Barcodes and product IDs. A product’s barcode is part of where it came from too. The UPC, short for Universal Product Code, is the barcode on most store products, and it carries a number called a GTIN, or Global Trade Item Number. GS1 US says the first 6 to 10 digits are a company ID “assigned exclusively by GS1,” and the next digits are assigned by the brand owner to identify the item. GS1 US also says, “Each distinct option requires its own individual GTIN,” and it names “different sizes, flavors, or packaging styles” as examples.

Walmart says it “requires that all items sold on Walmart Marketplace have product IDs,” and it checks them against GS1’s database and removes listings with invalid ones. Amazon uses GTINs to match an offer to an existing listing or to create a new one, and its guide says a seller who buys from a manufacturer but doesn’t have the GTIN can request it from them.

Test 3: Shipping and Handling

Size, weight and how easily something breaks all matter. A bigger or heavier product costs more to ship, and a fragile one is more likely to arrive damaged and come back as a return. Marketplaces score stores on on-time delivery and returns, so a product that ships well helps the store’s standing, and What Account Health Means on Every Marketplace spells out those scores.

UPS says, “Dimensional weight is the amount of space a package occupies compared to its actual weight,” and it uses dimensional weight to figure shipping costs when a package is large for how much it weighs. The math multiplies the box’s length, width and height and divides by a number UPS sets, so a large, light package can be charged as though it weighed more.

Some products count as hazardous materials, which USPS defines as substances that could hurt people or cause damage when handled the wrong way, like chemicals or flammable items. USPS says some of them can’t go through the mail at all, and others can only travel by ground, never by plane. Its examples include small consumer lithium batteries, like the ones in cameras and flashlights, which are mailable within the US under certain conditions, and perfume containing alcohol, which can’t be mailed domestically by air. Aerosols and gases have their own rules, and USPS points mailers to its Publication 52 to check whether an item is mailable.

Fragile items need more protection. UPS says, “The two-box method is recommended for sharp or fragile goods,” and more packing makes a bigger box, which brings dimensional weight back into it.

Test 4: Fit for Each Marketplace

Each marketplace reaches shoppers in its own way and has its own rules, so a product gets checked against every marketplace it’ll be listed on. TikTok Shop sells through short videos and LIVE, and Etsy’s Creativity Standards limit what can go there, as the posts linked under Test 1 show.

Why We Buy Wholesale

Amazon describes retail arbitrage as buying products from retail stores and reselling them. Wholesale means buying from the manufacturer or an authorized distributor, usually in bulk, with an invoice that shows the product’s source, and that’s the kind of document Amazon asks for when a product needs approval.

We buy wholesale and no longer do retail arbitrage, so every product we buy for a client comes from a supplier with an invoice behind it.

How We Decide What to Reorder

Passing the tests earns a product a small first order, and its sales decide the next step. We reorder what keeps selling with a healthy margin and hold items that don’t have enough history yet. We stop reordering slow sellers and products with weak margins, high returns or listing problems. The owner approves any added product money, and the team picks the items.

Read Next

Once a product passes those tests and gets bought, it starts a trip of its own: What Happens to Inventory Between the Supplier and the Customer.

Go to Post 20 →

In This SectionBehind the Warehouse DoorSee all posts in this sectionAll posts

Start Your 5-Store Portfolio

Apply in a few minutes. We'll reply within 1 business day. No obligation.

Contact us

Warehouse: Norcross, GA

Operations: Estero, FL

GA (678) 809-0227

FL (561) 559-9415

Gateway Capital Growth logo
Gateway Capital Growth logo

© 2026 GCG. All rights reserved.

Start Your 5-Store Portfolio

Apply in a few minutes. We'll reply within 1 business day. No obligation.

Contact us

Warehouse: Norcross, GA

Operations: Estero, FL

GA (678) 809-0227

FL (561) 559-9415

Gateway Capital Growth logo
Gateway Capital Growth logo

© 2026 GCG. All rights reserved.

Start Your 5-Store Portfolio

Apply in a few minutes. We'll reply within 1 business day. No obligation.

Contact us

Warehouse: Norcross, GA

Operations: Estero, FL

GA (678) 809-0227

FL (561) 559-9415

Gateway Capital Growth logo
Gateway Capital Growth logo

© 2026 GCG. All rights reserved.

Start Your 5-Store Portfolio

Apply in a few minutes. We'll reply within 1 business day. No obligation.

Contact us

Warehouse: Norcross, GA

Operations: Estero, FL

GA (678) 809-0227

FL (561) 559-9415

Gateway Capital Growth logo
Gateway Capital Growth logo

© 2026 GCG. All rights reserved.