
This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.
The 2-minute Version
✔
States can tie tax obligations to a business in 2 ways, through its sales into the state or through a physical presence there, and inventory stored in a warehouse can count as presence.
✔
Washington lists “Having a stock of goods in Washington” as physical presence, and the Streamlined Sales Tax group says a seller with physical presence in a state is expected to register there.
✔
Marketplace facilitator laws move most of the collecting to the marketplaces, and some states still expect a marketplace seller with physical presence to register or file.
✔
For state income tax, a federal law protects sellers whose only activity in a state is asking for orders, and the states that work through the Multistate Tax Commission take the position that keeping inventory there goes beyond that protection.
✔
The answer depends on the state, so the owner’s tax professional reads the rules for the state where the inventory is stored and the states where the store sells.
Most online store owners don’t live next door to their inventory. The products are stored in a fulfillment center, and that building is often in a different state from the owner’s home and the business’s address.
That distance doesn’t matter to a shopper, and it can matter to a state’s tax department, for sales tax and for income tax. The rules change from state to state, so the details for any 1 store are a question for a tax professional.
2 Kinds of Connection to a State
A state can only make a business collect its sales tax when the business has a strong enough connection there, which tax people call nexus. The first kind comes from sales. Since the Supreme Court’s 2018 decision in South Dakota v. Wayfair, states can use sales thresholds, so a business can have nexus in a state just by selling enough there, the side of nexus How Sales Tax Works When You Sell on Marketplaces already covers.
The second kind is older and simpler, which is being physically present in the state. The Streamlined Sales Tax Governing Board, a group of states that coordinates sales tax rules, says, “Economic nexus laws apply to any business that makes sales into states in which they have no physical presence,” and obligations for sellers with physical presence “did not change under the Wayfair decision.”
Inventory as Physical Presence
Physical presence can be a store, an office or employees, and in many states it can also be inventory. Washington’s Department of Revenue lists, as an example of physical presence, “Having a stock of goods in Washington, including inventory held by a marketplace facilitator.” It adds, “Physical presence is a nexus standard that requires only more than the slightest presence.” Each state writes its own rules, and the Streamlined Sales Tax board puts the general idea this way: a seller with a physical presence in a state isn’t a remote seller and has to register there, whatever its sales.
When the Marketplace Collects and a Registration Is Still Needed
Under marketplace facilitator laws, the marketplace collects the sales tax on orders placed through it. That handles most of the tax on most orders, and it doesn’t end the seller’s paperwork in every state.
Washington says a seller with physical presence has to register even below the state’s economic threshold, and that the seller still files its business and occupation tax when it meets a registration threshold. Texas says a Texas seller that sells through a marketplace is “still responsible for having a Texas tax permit,” and that this holds even when all of the seller’s sales go through a marketplace provider. The Streamlined Sales Tax board’s guidance for marketplace sellers says the seller “may also be required to register and file returns for sales and use tax purposes in that state.”
Other states take a lighter approach, and some leave marketplace sales out when they count a seller’s sales toward their thresholds.
State Income Tax and Public Law 86-272
Income tax works on a different set of rules. A 1959 federal law, Public Law 86-272, bars a state from taxing a business’s net income when its only activity in the state is soliciting orders for physical goods that are approved and shipped from outside the state.
A group of states reads that protection narrowly. The Multistate Tax Commission, an organization of state tax agencies, lists “Warehouse” and “Stock of goods other than samples” among activities the law doesn’t protect. It also gives an example of a business whose products are stored in fulfillment centers in several states and concludes that “This maintenance of the business’s products defeats the business’s P.L. 86-272 immunity” in those states. That’s the position of the commission and the states that support it. Some states also have taxes on gross receipts or franchise taxes that work differently from income tax, like Washington’s business and occupation tax mentioned above.
What This Means for a Store
A store that ships from 1 fulfillment center keeps its inventory in 1 state, which keeps the question focused, while a store using a marketplace’s network of warehouses can end up with inventory in many states at once. Picture an owner who lives in 1 state, whose LLC is registered there and whose inventory is stored in a fulfillment center 2 states away, with every order going through marketplaces. The marketplaces collect sales tax for the states where shoppers live, and the owner’s home state taxes the business’s income the usual way. The warehouse state may treat the stored inventory as physical presence, which can mean a sales tax registration even with little or nothing to collect, and possibly an income or franchise tax filing under its reading of Public Law 86-272.
That example turns into a few questions for a tax professional. Does the state where the inventory is stored expect the business to register for sales tax, even with every sale going through a marketplace? Does it expect an income, franchise or gross receipts tax return? Which other states has the business reached by sales thresholds, and do those states count marketplace sales? And what records should the owner keep to answer a state’s questions later?
Where Our Warehouse Fits In
Our agreement names the state where our warehouse is, and once inventory goes into Walmart, Amazon or TikTok Shop fulfillment, those marketplaces decide which of their warehouses hold it, so an owner’s tax professional can include both in the review. The agreement leaves tax decisions, registrations and filings with the owner, and it has us help spot states where the store’s sales data suggests an economic threshold may have been reached, which the agreement calls informational only.
Read Next
The tax side stays with the owner’s business no matter who runs the stores, and leaving a service raises questions of its own: What Happens to Your Accounts, Inventory and Records When You Leave a Service.
Go to Post 45 →

