
This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.
The 2-minute Version
✔
A package that goes missing or arrives broken usually starts 2 processes, the shopper’s refund through the marketplace and a claim with the carrier.
✔
USPS, UPS and FedEx each set their own claim windows, and all 3 ask for proof of value, photos of any damage and the original box.
✔
A carrier’s included coverage or declared value caps what it pays, FedEx says plainly that declared value isn’t insurance, and USPS won’t pay for an item packed too poorly to survive the trip.
✔
Walmart, TikTok Shop and Amazon take on some lost-package refunds when the seller buys labels through them, and eBay’s and Etsy’s protections cover sellers who ship on time with valid tracking.
✔
When a shopper says a delivered package was stolen, proof of delivery, like a photo or a signature, is what a seller needs to push back.
Sooner or later, a store deals with a box that never shows up, a box that arrives crushed or a shopper who says it vanished from the porch, even though most packages arrive fine. Returns and refunds in general belong to What Happens to the Money When a Customer Returns an Order. A package that fails along the way runs on 2 tracks at once. The shopper’s refund goes through the marketplace, and the seller’s claim goes to the carrier, or to the marketplace when it sold the label.
Filing a Claim With the Carrier
USPS says, “Either the sender or the recipient may file a claim for insured mail that is lost, arrived damaged, or was missing contents.” A damaged package can be claimed right away and no later than 60 days after mailing. A lost Priority Mail or Ground Advantage package can be claimed from 15 days after mailing up to day 60. USPS asks for proof of value, like a receipt, and photos of the damage, and it says, “Do not throw out damaged items, even after you photograph them.” Its mail manual also rules out paying for “any item packaged in such a manner that it could not have reached its destination undamaged,” and a denied claim can be appealed within 30 days.
UPS tells shippers to “Start a claim within 60 days of the scheduled delivery for packages that have been lost or damaged,” and to keep the invoice and the damaged contents and packaging. Its photo list covers the damaged item and how it was packed, the label with the tracking number and the outside of the box. FedEx gives 60 calendar days from the ship date for damaged US packages and 9 months for lost ones. It asks for a copy of the vendor’s invoice, photos and the original packaging until the claim is resolved.
Included Coverage, Declared Value and Insurance
Carrier coverage has a ceiling, since USPS includes up to $100 of insurance in the price of Priority Mail and Ground Advantage and FedEx includes a standard $100 limit of liability. A more valuable package needs a higher declared value or added insurance. FedEx explains that “The declared value of a package represents our maximum liability in connection with the shipment of that package,” and it says plainly, “Declared value is not shipping insurance.” Even with a higher declared value, FedEx says its liability won’t go past the repair cost, the depreciated value or the replacement cost, whichever is less.
Marketplaces sell coverage too. eBay offers ShipCover insurance through Parcel Insurance Plan on USPS, UPS and FedEx labels bought on eBay. Its claim rules ask sellers to wait at least 7 days after the sale for a damaged item and at least 30 days after the estimated delivery date for a lost one. Coverage for inventory still on a warehouse shelf is a different policy, which The Insurance a Store Owner Carries and the Insurance Marketplaces Require covers.
What Each Marketplace Does
Walmart: On orders that go out on Walmart’s own labels, Walmart won’t seek reimbursement from the seller, up to a set amount, for refunds on orders “reported as lost in transit or after delivery.” It adds, “Walmart manages the claims process directly with the carrier, so no action is required from you.” Packages damaged in transit aren’t covered, and the on-time score protection that comes with these labels is in What Account Health Means on Every Marketplace.
TikTok Shop: With TikTok Shipping, “Once the package is handed over and scanned, TikTok assumes responsibility.” TikTok approves seller reimbursement automatically for packages lost in transit, delivered but not received or delivered late. It reviews damage case by case with photo or video proof, and the seller pays for a package that was poorly packed. Claims have to be opened within 60 days of the order date, and TikTok tells sellers on Seller Shipping, “You handle claims directly with your LSP,” meaning their own carrier.
Amazon: For seller-fulfilled orders, Amazon says it will “refund costs for claims when customers report that packages don’t arrive” on labels bought through Amazon Buy Shipping, shipped on time, with buyer messages answered within 48 hours.
eBay: When a buyer reports an item that hasn’t arrived, eBay protects sellers who shipped within their handling time, uploaded tracking from an integrated carrier before the estimated delivery date and have tracking that shows delivery. Ship with eBay, where eBay handles “all qualifying claims and paperwork with the carrier,” is open to a limited number of individual sellers, and eBay’s page says accounts registered as a business aren’t eligible.
Etsy: Purchase Protection for Sellers covers orders that never arrive or arrive 7 or more days after the estimated delivery window, along with the seller’s first damaged-item case in a calendar year. Etsy refunds the buyer while “you’ll keep your earnings from the sale,” up to a set amount. The order has to ship within the processing time with valid tracking or an Etsy label, and the seller has to answer the buyer’s message within 48 hours. A seller with third-party or carrier insurance claims on that coverage first, since Etsy refunds only where other coverage doesn’t apply.
When the Shopper Says It Was Stolen
A package marked delivered that the shopper says never came is the hardest case, because the tracking already says the job is done. TikTok’s guidance has sellers help the shopper check the address, neighbors and carrier notes first. After that, the seller approves the refund when there’s no proof of delivery and the package can’t be found, or declines it with proof of delivery, which the shopper can appeal. TikTok notes that carriers like UPS provide photo proof and that USPS may offer a signature receipt for an added fee.
eBay builds the signature into its rules, since sellers need signature confirmation on orders totaling $750 or more to be protected when a buyer reports an item not received. Walmart’s label protection, described above, covers this case too.
The Records That Help
Almost every claim and dispute turns on the same few records. The tracking number has to be uploaded on time, as What Happens to Inventory Between the Supplier and the Customer explains, and the carrier’s scans show when the package left and where it ended up. Photos of the packed order before it’s sealed answer an empty-box or wrong-item claim, and the supplier’s invoice proves what the item cost. The damaged box and packing stay put until the claim closes, since USPS, UPS and FedEx all ask for them. During the agreement, our team handles customer dispute responses with the marketplaces on the owner’s behalf, and What Happens With Us When Something Goes Wrong covers the rest of our terms.
Read Next
Claims, tracking and declared value are a few of the terms store owners pick up along the way, and the guide’s glossary collects the rest: E-Commerce Terms Every Store Owner Hears.
Go to Post 60 →

