
This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.
The 2-minute Version
✔
Product reviews and seller feedback are what shoppers read before they buy, so every marketplace protects them with rules that sellers have to follow.
✔
Paying or rewarding someone for a positive review is banned on every marketplace in this guide, and Amazon, Walmart and Etsy also bar reviews from friends, family or people tied to the brand.
✔
Each marketplace has its own approved way to gather reviews, like Amazon’s Request a Review button and Vine, Walmart’s Review Accelerator and TikTok Shop’s review coupon.
✔
The FTC’s rule on consumer reviews, in effect since October 21, 2024, bans fake reviews, buying reviews that express a particular sentiment and using threats to get reviews removed, and knowing violations can bring civil penalties in court.
✔
A service that promises to “boost” a store’s reviews puts the owner’s account at risk, since the account holder answers for what happens on it.
A new listing with no reviews is a hard sell, and a seller looking at that empty star rating can feel a strong pull to fill it in fast. The marketplaces and the FTC have detailed rules about how reviews get gathered, and breaking them can cost a store far more than a few slow weeks.
Reviews and Feedback Are 2 Different Things
A product review is about the item, like whether a lamp is as bright as the listing says, and it usually shows on the product page for every seller of that item. Seller feedback is about the store, like whether the order arrived on time and in good shape. eBay calls it feedback, Etsy shows reviews on each shop, and Amazon, Walmart and TikTok Shop keep product reviews and their own measures of the seller’s service. Both kinds matter, and both are protected by the same basic rule: a review has to be a real customer’s honest opinion.
What Each Marketplace Bans
Amazon: “Selling partners cannot offer compensation in exchange for a positive or negative review.” Amazon tells sellers not to “influence customer ratings, feedback, and reviews, or make requests for customers to remove negative reviews or post positive reviews,” and it removes reviews from people with “a direct or indirect financial interest in the product” or a close personal relationship with its owner. Its enforcement can include “Suspending Amazon privileges” and “Litigating against the parties involved.”
Walmart: “You may not directly solicit reviews outside of Walmart’s Review Accelerator programs.” Its review policy also says, “Asking anyone with a personal or professional tie to your brand to leave a review is prohibited, regardless of intent,” and “Never condition refunds or returns on leaving a review.” Walmart can respond by “removing, suspending or banning third-party Marketplace sellers.”
eBay: “Feedback manipulation, which is any attempt to artificially increase your feedback score or lower another member’s, is not allowed,” including “Offering discounts, free items, or any other form of compensation, benefit, or incentive in exchange for positive feedback.” eBay also removes feedback used “as a means to extort another member,” like a buyer threatening a negative rating unless the seller throws in something free.
Etsy: Etsy prohibits shilling, and its examples include a seller who “Has a friend or family member purchase an item and leave a biased, inauthentic, or untruthful positive review.”
TikTok Shop: “Sellers must not offer rewards to persuade anyone to leave a product review,” and “Sellers must not use customer review services to persuade a positive or negative review.” TikTok says sellers who use those services “may face immediate selling privilege suspension,” and its guidance adds, “Do not ask for only positive reviews or suggest a star rating.”
The Approved Ways to Get Reviews
Every marketplace gives sellers a legitimate path, and each one is built so the review can go either way. Amazon lets sellers “Send automated review requests to customers by clicking Request a Review on the Order details page,” and its Vine program sends products to “trusted reviewers who Amazon has invited.” Vine is open to products with “Fewer than 30 reviews,” and brand products need to be enrolled in Amazon Brand Registry.
Walmart’s Review Accelerator has 2 programs. Post-Purchase Reviews offers customers an incentive after they buy, with every review “badged as Incentivized Review,” and Recognized Reviewer sends free samples to “a select group of trusted reviewers.” Both are open to items with fewer than 15 reviews.
TikTok Shop’s review coupon gives buyers a coupon for leaving a detailed review, and “A buyer will receive a coupon regardless of whether the review is positive or negative.” Those reviews carry an “Incentivized Review” label, so shoppers can see how they came in.
What a Seller Can Do About a Bad Review
An unfair review stings, and the rules leave a seller a few honest options. eBay removes feedback in specific cases, like “Personally identifiable information,” “Comments intended for a different item or seller” and “Negative comments with positive ratings, or positive comments with negative ratings.” Sellers can contact eBay “within 90 days of the transaction to request removal.” Etsy’s Seller Policy says reviews may not be about “things outside the seller’s control, such as a shipping carrier, Etsy or a third party.”
Beyond those cases, the best answer to a bad review is a calm public reply where the marketplace allows one and a fix for whatever caused it. Pressuring the customer to change it is off the table on every marketplace above.
The Federal Rule Behind All of It
The FTC’s rule on consumer reviews, covered in How to Research Any Done-for-You Seller Before Your First Call, applies whether or not a marketplace catches the problem first. It bans fake reviews, rewards tied to whether a review is positive or negative and threats or intimidation used to get a review removed, and knowing violations can bring civil penalties.
The FTC’s own guide adds 2 useful points. “The rule does not prohibit giving incentives for reviews, as long as there isn’t an express or implied requirement that the reviews have to express a particular sentiment,” which is how the programs above are allowed to work. And on asking only happy customers for reviews, the FTC says the rule doesn’t ban it outright, “But this practice could violate the FTC Act.”
Reviews and the Account Owner’s Responsibility
The marketplace holds the account owner responsible for what happens on the account, whoever does the work. Who Should Own the Store Accounts When Someone Else Runs Them covers that rule, and Etsy’s shared access page repeats it: “The shop owner is responsible for activity in their shop, including actions taken by team members.”
That makes reviews a fair topic to raise with any service company. Ask how it gathers reviews, which marketplace programs it uses, and whether it ever offers refunds, gifts or free products in exchange for a review. The right answer points to the marketplace’s own programs, and a vague promise of “review boosting” is a reason to walk away.
Read Next
Review rules are 1 of many that marketplaces update over time, and those changes reach sellers in a few ways: How Marketplace Rules Change and How a Store Keeps Up.
Go to Post 36 →

