
This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.
The 2-minute Version
✔
A marketplace comes with shoppers, a checkout and a rulebook. A business’s own website starts with no shoppers and leaves the rules to the business, which brings its own visitors and takes on jobs the marketplace used to handle.
✔
The FTC’s Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule covers online orders. A seller needs a reasonable basis for any shipping time it states and has to offer a choice between a delay and a refund when it can’t ship on time.
✔
A marketplace usually collects the sales tax on its sales, while on its own site the business collects and files it where it has nexus. Shopify says it doesn’t file or remit the tax unless the store sets up its automated filing.
✔
Payments run through the business’s own processor, so a chargeback goes from the shopper’s bank to the business, with a fee and the disputed amount coming out of a payout.
✔
Marketing email falls under the CAN-SPAM Act, and California’s online privacy law requires commercial websites that collect personal information from California consumers to post a privacy policy.
Owners sometimes ask whether the business should have a website of its own, next to the marketplaces or in place of them. A website carries the business’s own brand and keeps a direct line to its customers. It also hands the business a set of jobs that a marketplace handles in the background, from finding shoppers to payments, sales tax and customer disputes. None of what follows is legal or tax advice, and the tax pieces are a question for the owner’s tax professional.
Who Brings the Shoppers
A marketplace is a place shoppers already go to search, compare and buy, so a listing there competes for the attention of people who came to shop. The work is standing out among other sellers, with help from tools like the ones in How Marketplace Ads Work and Who Decides What a Store Spends. A business’s own website starts with no visitors at all. Shopify’s help page on search engine optimization asks, “how do you get customers to find your store?” and points to search rankings as 1 answer. Paid ads, social media and email can bring visitors too, and each takes money, time or both, so a plan for traffic belongs in the budget from the start.
Shipping Promises Under the FTC’s Mail Order Rule
The FTC’s Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule was issued in 1975. The FTC says, “It applies to most goods a customer orders from the seller by mail, telephone, fax, or on the Internet.” That wording doesn’t single out any type of website. On a marketplace, the marketplace’s own handling times and delivery standards also shape the promise, while on the business’s own site, the business writes the promise itself.
A seller needs “a reasonable basis for stating or implying that you can ship within a certain time.” With no time stated, the default is 30 days, which is why direct marketers sometimes call it the “30-day Rule.” When an order can’t ship on time, the seller has to offer “an option either to consent to a delay in shipping or to cancel the buyer’s order and receive a prompt refund.” For most payment methods, a refund is due within 7 working days after the order is cancelled, or within 1 billing cycle when the seller extended the credit. The FTC’s guide also lists times the seller has to treat an order as cancelled and refund it, like a customer taking up a cancellation option the seller offered before the order ships, or the seller finding it will never be able to ship the item.
Sales Tax Moves Back to the Business
On a marketplace, the facilitator laws in How Sales Tax Works When You Sell on Marketplaces put the collecting on the marketplace, and sales made outside a marketplace stay with the seller. A business’s own website is outside, so the business registers, charges tax at checkout, files returns and sends in the tax wherever it has nexus. Website sales count toward a state’s sales threshold, and some states, like New York, count marketplace sales toward it too, so the 2 channels together can cross a line that neither would cross alone.
The website software doesn’t take that job over by default. Shopify’s Help Center says, “Tax is your responsibility,” and “Shopify doesn’t remit or file your taxes for you, unless you use Shopify Tax and set up automated filing.” The Streamlined Sales Tax Governing Board, whose simplified rules 24 states have adopted, offers 1 registration for all of its member states. It also contracts with Certified Service Providers that can handle nearly all of a seller’s sales and use tax work, from figuring the tax at checkout to filing and paying it. The board says, “There is no charge for CSP services in the Streamlined Member States where the seller is a remote seller.”
Payments and Chargebacks
On a marketplace, the marketplace takes the shopper’s payment and steps in when a buyer and seller disagree. It does that through programs like eBay’s Money Back Guarantee and Amazon’s A-to-z Guarantee, covered in What Happens to the Money When a Customer Returns an Order. On a business’s own site, payments run through a processor the business signs up with and gets verified for, like Shopify Payments.
A chargeback then comes straight to the business. Shopify explains that a cardholder with an issue can “contact their bank to dispute the charge,” and that “the company that issued the cardholder’s credit card reviews any evidence” and decides. It adds that “Shopify isn’t involved in the decision making of chargeback outcomes.” The bank “also takes a chargeback fee from you,” and on Shopify Payments the amount comes out of the next available payout. Shopify can also hold back part of a store’s transactions as a reserve, a temporary hold that can follow a review finding signs of risk like “Elevated chargeback activity” or an “Increased refund rate.”
Email Lists and the Privacy Policy
A website can collect shoppers’ email addresses and market to them directly, and that email falls under the CAN-SPAM Act. The FTC’s compliance guide says, “It covers all commercial messages,” and “The law makes no exception for business-to-business email.” Each message needs honest header information and subject lines, has to be identified as an ad and must include “your valid physical postal address” and a way to opt out. On that last point, “You must honor a recipient’s opt-out request within 10 business days.” The FTC also says a business can’t contract away its legal responsibility by hiring another company to send its email, and each email that breaks the law can bring its own penalty.
The privacy policy is another new job. California’s online privacy law, as the state attorney general describes it, applies to “operators of commercial web sites or online services” that collect personal information on California consumers. Those operators have to “conspicuously post a privacy policy on the site” and follow it. The policy has to identify the categories of personal information collected, the categories of third parties it may be shared with and the site’s online tracking practices. A website reaches shoppers in California from anywhere, so the rule can apply to a store based in any state.
Where a Website Fits With the Marketplaces
A website can run next to the marketplaces, and the 2 work differently enough that each needs its own plan for visitors, payments, tax and customer service. With us, a client’s brand launches on Amazon, Walmart, TikTok Shop and eBay first to prove demand, and then we build the brand its own online store and run Facebook and Instagram ads to it.
Read Next
A marketplace’s rules reach all the way to who ships an order, which is where dropshipping comes in: Why Dropshipping Runs Into Marketplace Rules.
Go to Post 52 →
SOURCES

