
This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.
The 2-minute Version
✔
An LLC is a legal structure set up under state law, and the IRS taxes it as a disregarded entity, a partnership or a corporation, depending on its owners and its elections.
✔
The default for 1 owner is the owner’s personal return, and for 2 or more owners it’s a partnership return on Form 1065.
✔
An LLC can elect to be taxed as a corporation with Form 8832 or as an S corporation with Form 2553, which has to be filed within 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year it covers or during the year before.
✔
An S corporation has to pay an owner who works in the business reasonable compensation as wages before it makes other distributions, and the IRS lists the factors it weighs.
✔
Whatever the tax choice, marketplaces want the legal business name to match across the seller account, the bank, the tax ID and, for some, the insurance certificate.
Many people who open an online store ask the same question: should the business be an LLC or an S corporation? The question mixes up 2 separate choices, and pulling them apart makes the conversation with a tax professional much shorter.
The first choice is the legal structure, which a state creates when the business files its paperwork. The second is the tax treatment, which is how the IRS taxes that structure. An LLC is a legal structure, and an S corporation is a tax treatment that an LLC can elect, so a business can be both at once. The right answer depends on the owner’s whole situation, so treat what follows as background and leave the decision to the professional.
The Legal Structure
An LLC, or limited liability company, is formed under a state’s law by filing articles of organization, and a corporation is formed by filing articles of incorporation. Marketplaces expect a real business on the other side, which The Paperwork Every Marketplace Asks a New Seller For explains, and the legal structure is what gives the store its name, its tax ID and its bank account.
The legal side also carries state costs and filings, like annual reports and a registered agent, and those vary from state to state. A tax election doesn’t change the legal structure, so an LLC that elects S corporation treatment is still an LLC under state law.
How the IRS Taxes an LLC by Default
The IRS says that “an LLC with only one member is treated as an entity disregarded as separate from its owner,” and for an owner who’s a person, the business’s results go on Schedule C of the owner’s personal return. A disregarded LLC’s owner also owes self-employment tax on net earnings.
An LLC with 2 or more members is “classified as a partnership for federal income tax purposes” unless it elects otherwise, and it “should file a Form 1065, U.S. Return of Partnership Income.” Each member then reports a share of the results on their own return.
Electing a Different Treatment
An LLC can also choose to be taxed as a corporation, which means filing “a Form 1120, U.S. Corporation Income Tax Return,” and the election to get there is made on Form 8832, Entity Classification Election.
The election most store owners hear about is the S corporation. The IRS describes Form 2553 as the form “to make an election under section 1362(a) to be an S corporation.” Its instructions give 2 windows for filing, “No more than 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to take effect” or “At any time during the tax year preceding the tax year it is to take effect.” An LLC that makes the S election is “treated as a corporation as of the effective date of the S corporation election” and “doesn’t need to file Form 8832.” An S corporation files Form 1120-S, and the deadline belongs on the calendar, since an election filed late can end up taking effect a year later than planned.
What Changes With an S Corporation
The biggest change is how the owner gets paid. The IRS says, “S corporations must pay reasonable compensation to a shareholder-employee in return for services” the owner “provides to the corporation before non-wage distributions may be made to the shareholder-employee.” That means the business runs payroll for the owner, with the withholding and payroll filings that come with it.
The IRS lists the factors it weighs in deciding what’s reasonable, including “Training and experience,” “Duties and responsibilities,” “Time and effort devoted to the business” and “What comparable businesses pay for similar services.” How much time the owner actually spends on the business is 1 of those factors, and weighing it is the kind of judgment a professional should make with the owner. The split between wages and other distributions is where most of the S corporation questions are, along with the cost of running payroll and filing a corporate return every year.
Questions to Bring to a Tax Professional
These questions cover the main decisions.
How is the business taxed today, and what would change under an S election?
What would reasonable compensation look like for my role, given how much time I actually spend on the business?
What does payroll cost to run each year, and who handles the filings?
When would an election have to be filed to take effect for the year I want, and what happens when it’s late?
How does each choice affect the qualified business income deduction and my state taxes?
For a business with 2 or more owners, what does the operating agreement need to say about the tax treatment?
Why the Name Has to Match Everywhere
Whatever the tax choice, the marketplaces care that the business’s name and tax ID match across every account, as How Walmart Decides Whether to Approve a New Seller and The Insurance a Store Owner Carries and the Insurance Marketplaces Require both show. Changing them later can send a seller account back through verification, so the time to settle the structure is before the store applications go in, with the professional’s help.
What We Ask For Before Setup
Our agreement asks for an approved LLC or corporation before store setup begins, along with an EIN from the IRS, a reseller certificate or sales tax permit where it applies, a bank account opened in the business’s name and a recent statement from that account. The owner’s tax professional decides how that business is taxed.
Read Next
Where a business sells and stores its inventory can matter for taxes too, and inventory kept in another state is the next piece: What Storing Inventory in Another State Can Mean for Taxes.
Go to Post 44 →

