What to Ask When You Call Owners on a Seller’s Reference List

What to Ask When You Call Owners on a Seller’s Reference List

Post

14

A phone beside a 3-step checklist for calling a seller's references.

This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.

The 2-minute Version

✔

The FTC’s disclosure form names people who bought in the last 3 years, with a state and phone number for each one.

✔

The seller has to disclose any payment or other relationship it has with a person it presents as a buyer, and the FTC warns that some promoters have named “insiders” who give bogus recommendations.

✔

Read the disclosure document first, write your questions down and pick the people you call yourself, beyond the few the seller might suggest.

✔

The questions that tell you the most are about each owner’s experience, like how onboarding went, how problems get handled and whether what they got matched what they were told.

✔

Take notes, look for patterns across the calls and bring any differences back to the seller in writing.

The reference list is the only part of a disclosure package where you hear from somebody besides the seller. It’s a list of real people who bought the same opportunity, with their phone numbers, and a few calls to them are worth making during the 7 days.

The references section of the FTC’s form says, “You may wish to contact the people below to compare their experiences with what [the seller] told you about the business opportunity.”

What the Rules Say About the List

What a Business Opportunity Disclosure Document Has to Tell You explains how the list is built, from the 3-year window to the 10 buyers nearest you.

The rule also protects the list itself. A seller can’t misrepresent that someone bought the opportunity or can give an independent or reliable report about it, and it has to disclose anything it promised or paid to a person it presents as a buyer. That covers payments, forgiven debts, and equipment, services or discounts given to that person or to someone else on their behalf.

The same goes for any personal relationship, or any past or present business relationship besides being a buyer, so look for that statement, or ask the seller for it, before you start dialing. Another line says a seller can’t misrepresent that a law, regulation or government agency bars it from telling you who its other buyers are.

The FTC’s business guidance warns that some questionable promoters have been known to name “insiders” who give glowing recommendations that turn out to be bogus.

Getting Ready Before the First Call

Read the disclosure document before you dial. The FTC’s guidance says to use the waiting period to check out the information in the document, including contacting references, and knowing what the seller put in writing tells you what to listen for.

Next, write your questions down, so every owner hears the same ones and your notes line up afterward.

Then make your list of people to call. The FTC’s advice is to choose whom to contact yourself and not to rely only on the few people a seller suggests. A good mix makes the calls more useful:

  • Call some owners near you and some farther away.

  • Talk to some who bought recently and some who bought closer to 3 years ago.

  • Decide before you start how many owners you want to reach, and pick a few extra names, since not everyone picks up.

A recent buyer remembers the start clearly, and someone further along knows what came after.

Opening the Call

An owner who talks to you is doing you a favor, so start by saying who you are and where you got the number. A simple opening works well: “Hi, my name is Dana. I’m looking at buying a done-for-you store from [the seller], and your name was on their reference list. Do you have about 10 minutes to tell me about your experience?”

Offer to call back at an hour that suits them. Once the call gets going, let the owner do most of the talking, and when an answer is brief, a follow-up like “What happened after that?” brings out the detail.

When nobody answers, leave a short voicemail or text with your name, the seller’s name, where you found the number and a good time to reach you. Try once more on another day at a different time, then move to the next name and note who you couldn’t reach, because a missed call by itself doesn’t tell you anything.

The Questions That Tell You the Most

The best questions are about each owner’s own experience. You probably won’t get through all of them on every call, so star the ones that matter most to you and ask those first.

1. How long ago did you buy, and how far along is your setup? The answer tells you which stage the rest of their story describes. 2. How did onboarding go, and did it follow the steps you were told about? 3. Does what you got match what you were told and what’s in your contract? This one comes from the FTC, which suggests asking owners whether the seller’s information matches their experience with the company. 4. How does the team communicate, and how quickly do your questions get answered? You’ll hear what working with the seller feels like week to week. 5. Who do you go to when something goes wrong, and how was the last problem handled? Problems happen in every business, and the response to them tells you a lot. 6. How did setting up your marketplace accounts go, and how much help did you get with the paperwork? This shows what support came with 1 of the first steps an owner takes part in. 7. What did you have to handle yourself, and was that what you expected? The answer reveals whether the owner’s own jobs were described clearly. 8. How much of your own time does the store take in a normal month? Comparing this across owners shows what’s typical. 9. Were the costs and the bills what the paperwork said they’d be? 10. What surprised you, good or bad? Open questions bring up things you wouldn’t think to ask about. 11. Knowing what you know now, what would you ask before signing? Owners often hand you your best follow-up question here. 12. Do you have any relationship with the seller besides being a buyer? The answer should match the seller’s disclosure.

Making Sense of What You Hear

Write up your notes right after each call, while the details are fresh. A simple page works, with the date, the owner’s state, how long ago they bought and a line or 2 under each question you asked.

Then read the notes side by side, because when several owners bring up the same point on their own, good or bad, it probably reflects how the seller works. Some differences are normal, since owners bought at different times, are at different stages and take on different amounts of work themselves.

When the seller’s story, the paperwork and what owners tell you don’t line up, the FTC’s advice is to slow down. The best next step is to put your questions to the seller in writing and ask for written answers.

Our Reference List

Every buyer gets our reference list in the disclosure package, and you can pick whoever you want from it and ask them anything.

For Your Checklist

Call a few owners you pick yourself, and ask whether their experience matches what they were told.

Read Next

Owners can tell you what happened, and reading what a pitch says will happen starts with 2 words that appear everywhere: What “Passive Income” Means When It Shows Up in an Online Store Offer.

Go to Post 15 →

In This SectionChecking Out Any OfferSee all posts in this sectionAll posts

Start Your Private Label Brand

Apply in a few minutes. We'll reply within 1 business day. No obligation.

Contact us

Warehouse: Norcross, GA

Operations: Estero, FL

GA (678) 809-0227

FL (561) 559-9415

Gateway Capital Growth logo
Gateway Capital Growth logo

© 2026 GCG. All rights reserved.

Start Your Private Label Brand

Apply in a few minutes. We'll reply within 1 business day. No obligation.

Contact us

Warehouse: Norcross, GA

Operations: Estero, FL

GA (678) 809-0227

FL (561) 559-9415

Gateway Capital Growth logo
Gateway Capital Growth logo

© 2026 GCG. All rights reserved.

Start Your Private Label Brand

Apply in a few minutes. We'll reply within 1 business day. No obligation.

Contact us

Warehouse: Norcross, GA

Operations: Estero, FL

GA (678) 809-0227

FL (561) 559-9415

Gateway Capital Growth logo
Gateway Capital Growth logo

© 2026 GCG. All rights reserved.

Start Your Private Label Brand

Apply in a few minutes. We'll reply within 1 business day. No obligation.

Contact us

Warehouse: Norcross, GA

Operations: Estero, FL

GA (678) 809-0227

FL (561) 559-9415

Gateway Capital Growth logo
Gateway Capital Growth logo

© 2026 GCG. All rights reserved.