Post
15

This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.
The 2-minute Version
✔
In plain words, “passive income” means money that comes in without your own daily work, and in an online store that daily work still gets done by somebody.
✔
The IRS uses “passive” as a tax label for an owner who doesn’t materially participate, and its tests weigh the hours hired help puts in and treat reading reports as investor work.
✔
The FTC’s rule counts a statement as an earnings claim even when a buyer can only infer an income level from it, and the FTC says words that are literally true can still mislead in context.
✔
In 2021 the FTC sent a notice to more than 1,100 businesses that pitch money-making ventures, naming practices it has found deceptive, like misrepresenting, even by implication, that buyers are likely to profit or don’t need experience.
✔
Turn any income wording into questions about who does the work, which costs come out, how many buyers reached the result and where the written proof is.
Scroll through ads for online store offers and you’ll see “passive income” again and again, often in the first line. The phrase sounds simple, and yet tax law, the FTC and the people who write ads each use “passive” in their own way, so knowing all 3 makes any pitch easier to read.
What “Passive” Means in Plain Words
In everyday talk, “passive income” is money that keeps coming in while somebody else does the daily work, like rent from an apartment building that a property manager runs, so the owner’s time can go to other things.
An online store is a little different, since every order still has to be handled. Someone picks the products and buys the inventory, writes the listings, packs and ships each box, answers shopper messages and keeps the marketplace account in good standing. When a team runs the store, that work moves to the team and keeps going.
So the useful question about any passive claim is who does each job, and even in a store someone else runs, the owner keeps a short list of jobs, which What a Store Owner Does Each Month lays out.
How the IRS Uses the Word
The tax code uses “passive” with a narrow meaning of its own. IRS Publication 925 names 2 kinds of passive activities, trade or business activities “in which you don’t materially participate during the year” and, with some exceptions, rental activities.
Material participation is the IRS’s measure of how involved an owner is, and Publication 925 gives 7 tests for it. The first is “You participated in the activity for more than 500 hours.” Another asks whether your participation was “substantially all the participation in the activity of all individuals for the tax year,” and that count includes people “who didn’t own any interest in the activity,” so the hours that hired help puts in get weighed too. The third test looks for more than 100 hours in the year, with you putting in “at least as much as any other individual,” again including people who didn’t own any part of it.
The publication also separates running a business from watching it. “Studying and reviewing financial statements or reports on operations of the activity” counts as investor work, and investor work isn’t participation unless “you’re directly involved in the day-to-day management or operations of the activity.” The same list of investor work names “Monitoring the finances or operations of the activity in a nonmanagerial capacity.”
In tax law, then, passive describes the owner’s role, and it says nothing about how much work the business takes or what it earns. This is general information, not tax advice, and whether any activity counts as passive for you is a question for your accountant.
What the FTC Says About Income Language
The FTC reads income wording from the buyer’s side, and its Business Opportunity Rule treats any representation of a particular amount or range of sales or income, made “expressly or by implication,” as an earnings claim. Sales, Profit and Payout Are 3 Different Numbers explains that definition and the rule for earnings claims in ads.
The definition also reaches “Any statements from which a prospective purchaser can reasonably infer that he or she will earn a minimum level of income,” and 1 of the rule’s own examples is “earn enough to buy a Porsche.” A statement can be an earnings claim without a single number in it, and the FTC’s guidance for buyers adds that “Phrases like ‘up to’ aren’t a way out for the seller.”
The FTC’s guide for sellers warns that even a literally true statement “still could be deceptive in context.” The rule also forbids spreading “industry financial, earnings, or performance information” without written proof that it reflects, or doesn’t exceed, what buyers of that opportunity typically experience.
Florida’s list of prohibited acts says business opportunity sellers shall not “Misrepresent the amount of profits, net or gross, which the franchisee can expect from the operation of the business opportunity,” and it also bars creating “a false or misleading impression in the sale of a business opportunity.”
The FTC’s Notice About Money-Making Claims
On October 26, 2021, the FTC sent a Notice of Penalty Offenses to “more than 1,100 businesses that pitch money-making ventures,” a group that included business opportunities, franchises and business coaching. A notice like this lists conduct the Commission has already found unfair or deceptive in earlier administrative orders, and the FTC says it “allows the agency to seek civil penalties against a company that engages in conduct that it knows is unlawful.” The FTC also says receiving one “does not indicate that the Commission has reason to believe it is breaking the law.”
The notice on money-making opportunities names practices like these as unfair or deceptive:
Misrepresenting, “explicitly or implicitly, that participants will be or are likely to be profitable.”
Presenting earnings figures as typical without the context buyers need, “such as the time and effort actually expended by participants who made the amount represented.”
Leaving out “conditions or limitations affecting such income, such as expenses to be borne by the participant.”
Misrepresenting “that participants do not need experience in order to earn income.”
What FTC Cases Say About Online Store Pitches
The phrase turns up in the FTC’s own cases against online store sellers, and what follows comes from the FTC’s allegations as its press releases describe them. In a case the FTC announced in September 2024, it says the sellers falsely claimed their tools would help buyers earn “passive income by opening online storefronts.”
In a case filed in 2025, the FTC alleged that the sellers “promised to create and operate stores for consumers on Amazon and other third-party e-commerce platforms” that would bring in guaranteed “passive income,” and that they “made false and unsubstantiated claims about potential earnings.”
How to Read Income Language in Any Offer
These 5 questions work on income wording in any offer: 1. Who does each job in the store, and which jobs stay with me? The answer shows whose work the passive part depends on. 2. Is a number sales, payout or profit, and which costs come out first? 3. How many of all the buyers reached a result, and over what dates? A single owner’s story says little about what’s typical. 4. Can I see the written proof? Under the rule, a seller making an earnings claim has “written materials that substantiate its claim” and makes them available to a prospective buyer “upon request.” 5. What does the earnings section of the disclosure document say? What a Business Opportunity Disclosure Document Has to Tell You shows where that section is and what comes with a yes.
The FTC’s consumer advice suggests working through questions of your own before buying into any business offer, including “How would the business generate income?” and “What would my specific expenses be?” Ask the seller to answer them in writing, so you can line the answers up against the disclosure document and the contract later.
For Your Checklist
For any income wording in an offer, ask who does the work behind it and ask for the written proof.
Read Next
Most pitches pair income language with a promise about what happens to your money when things don’t go as planned: How to Read Guarantees and Refund Promises in an Online Store Offer.
Go to Post 16 →
SOURCES
FTC, Selling a Work-at-Home or Other Business Opportunity? Revised Rule May Apply to You
FTC, FTC Puts Businesses on Notice that False Money-Making Claims Could Lead to Big Penalties
FTC, Notice of Penalty Offenses Concerning Money-Making Opportunities (PDF)
FTC, FTC Announces Crackdown on Deceptive AI Claims and Schemes
FTC Consumer Advice, When a Business Offer or Coaching Program Is a Scam

