Post
8

This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.
The 2-minute Version
✔
Sales is what shoppers paid for their orders, and what’s left once refunds come out is called net sales.
✔
Payout is what the marketplace deposits for the seller after it takes out its fees, refunds and any labels, on its own calendar.
✔
Profit is what’s left after the cost of the products that sold and every other cost of running the store.
✔
Each number follows a different date on the order, so sales show up first, the payout comes days or weeks later and profit comes once the month’s costs are in.
✔
Whenever you read a store report or an ad, ask which of the 3 numbers it shows, and know that the FTC counts a sales figure in a business opportunity offer as an earnings claim.
Ask 3 people how a store did last month and you can get 3 different answers that are all correct, because each person is looking at a different number: sales, what the marketplace paid out, or profit. The 3 are connected, but they measure different things, and mixing them up causes a lot of confusion.
Sales: What Shoppers Paid
Sales is the total shoppers paid for their orders, and you’ll also hear it called revenue or gross sales. It’s the first number anyone sees, because it shows up the moment an order comes in, and it’s the biggest of the 3.
The IRS uses nearly the same words. Publication 583 says “gross receipts are the income you receive from your business,” and line 1 of Schedule C, the IRS form for a business’s profit or loss, reads “Gross receipts or sales.”
When a shopper returns an order and gets a refund, that sale reverses, and Schedule C takes refunds off on its “Returns and allowances” line, leaving what’s often called net sales. What Happens to the Money When a Customer Returns an Order follows a refund through each marketplace.
Payout: What the Marketplace Sends
On a marketplace, the shopper pays the marketplace, and the marketplace then sends the seller a payout. Before it does, it takes out its own fees, along with any refunds it gave shoppers and any shipping labels the seller bought through it, and some marketplaces also hold part of a new seller’s money for a while. What’s left gets deposited on the marketplace’s calendar, and that deposit is the payout.
A consignment shop works much like this, since it takes the customer’s money at the register, keeps its cut and settles up with the owner of the goods on a set schedule.
Profit: What’s Left After Every Cost
Profit is what’s left after paying for everything it took to make the sales. That list starts with the products themselves and the marketplace fees, and it also includes shipping labels, returns and running costs like packing, storage and software, which usually get billed once a month.
Accountants split that list into 2 parts. The first is the cost of goods sold, which is what the store paid for the products that sold. IRS Publication 334 says a business values its inventory at the beginning and end of each tax year “to determine your cost of goods sold.”
A hardware store owner thinks about it the same way, counting the hammers sold this month against this month’s sales while the ones still on the wall stay inventory. What’s left of net sales after the cost of goods sold is gross profit, which is line 5 on Schedule C.
The second part is what Publication 583 calls expenses, “the costs you incur (other than the cost of inventory) to carry on your business.” Gross profit minus those expenses is net profit, which Schedule C reports as “Net profit or (loss).”
The product cost is the easiest one to forget. The product was bought before it sold, so its cost doesn’t come out of the payout, and it still counts against the sale. Why Inventory Gets Bought Before It Sells explains the timing.
Why They Show Up at Different Times
Every order has an order date, a ship date, a delivery date and a payout date. Sales follow the first one and payouts follow the later ones, and TikTok’s finance guide says its settlement clock starts “upon the successful delivery of the order to the customer, not on the order date.” Profit can only be worked out once every cost for the period is in, which is why stores run on a monthly statement.
The IRS describes 2 main ways to put those dates in a set of books. Under the cash method, Publication 334 says income counts when it’s received, so an order from late in a month can end up in the next month’s books. Under an accrual method, income generally counts when it’s earned, since “the purpose of an accrual method of accounting is to match income and expenses in the correct year.” Which method a business uses for its taxes is a question for its accountant.
What Each Marketplace Calls These Numbers
Marketplace | The sales side | The payout side |
|---|---|---|
Walmart | “Gross Sales Revenue,” item sales “not including shipping,” with refunds on their own line | “Payable to Partner from Sale,” defined as “sales minus commission” |
TikTok Shop | “Gross sales,” with refunds, seller discounts and “Net sales” in separate columns | “Total settlement amount,” built from net sales, shipping, fees and adjustments |
eBay | “Gross transaction amount,” the total “before any fees or credits are applied” | “Net amount,” the total “after any fees or credits are applied” |
Etsy | “Total sales,” with refunds shown separately | “Net,” which Etsy defines as “the gross amount of the sale minus fees and taxes” |
Amazon | Sales, added to each period’s starting balance | The payout, sent after expenses, refunds and a reserve come out |
Etsy’s Payment account also shows a Net profit line, defined as “the total of funds from your sales, minus any refunds, fees, shipping costs, and taxes.” What the products cost isn’t on that list, so it still has to come out before the store’s own profit is known.
How to Read Any Report or Ad
Any time you look at a store report, a dashboard or an ad, 3 quick questions tell you what you’re looking at: 1. Is this number sales, payout or profit? 2. What stretch of time does it cover, a day, a week or a month? 3. Does it come before or after the cost of the products?
The FTC treats even a sales figure as an earnings claim, since its Business Opportunity Rule covers any representation that conveys “a specific level or range of actual or potential sales, or gross or net income or profits.” A business opportunity seller can use one in an ad only alongside the dates those results were achieved and how many buyers, by number and percentage, reached at least that level.
So for any figure in an offer, also ask what share of all buyers got there. What “Passive Income” Means When It Shows Up in an Online Store Offer goes into the income wording offers use.
Our owners see these numbers each day on a dashboard and each month on a statement, and What the Daily Dashboard and Monthly Statement Show a Store Owner walks through both.
Read Next
The first thing that comes out of a sale on its way to a payout is the marketplace’s own fee, and every marketplace publishes how it charges: The Fees a Marketplace Takes Before It Pays You.
Go to Post 9 →

