
This post is part of GCG's guide to how online stores work, which starts with What Done for You Means in E-Commerce and How It Differs From a Course.
The 2-minute Version
✔
A shopper who buys from a store on a marketplace is also the marketplace’s customer, so every marketplace in this guide limits how a seller contacts that shopper and uses the order details.
✔
Walmart’s agreement says the order information belongs to Walmart and bars using it for marketing, and TikTok Shop and Etsy limit how sellers use buyer details.
✔
eBay, Etsy and TikTok Shop ban offers to buy or sell off their sites, and Amazon and Walmart keep marketing, coupons and outside links out of messages to buyers.
✔
The marketplaces give 3 reasons: their buyer protection only covers sales made on the platform, deals moved elsewhere invite fraud, and those deals skip the marketplace’s fees.
✔
Breaking these rules can bring warnings, removed listings and suspension, and the account holder answers for all of it.
An owner who already sells somewhere else, like a shop in town or a website, often looks at a first marketplace order and sees a new customer for the email list. The marketplaces see it differently, since the shopper found the product on their site, paid through their checkout and is counting on their buyer protection. So they hand the seller that shopper’s details for 1 job, getting the order delivered.
The Order Details Are for the Order
Walmart’s Retailer Agreement calls the order information Walmart sends a seller Transaction Information, meaning what Walmart “determines is necessary to fulfill each Order.” The agreement says “Walmart.com owns (and you hereby assign to Walmart.com) all Transaction Information.” A seller can’t use it “to conduct customer surveys or for any marketing or promotional purposes,” or use what it learns about Walmart’s customers to “directly solicit such Walmart.com Customers through any other sales channels.”
TikTok Shop’s Customer Service Policy says sellers “are prohibited from using customers’ personal information in any way other than to fulfill orders placed on TikTok Shop.” Etsy’s Seller Policy says a buyer’s email address or other details that come with a sale “may only be used for Etsy-related communications or for Etsy-facilitated transactions.” eBay keeps contact details private to begin with, saying, “We replace email addresses with aliases for buyers and sellers to hide personal contact information.”
No Deals Outside the Marketplace
eBay’s policy opens with “Offering to buy or sell outside of eBay is not allowed.” Before a sale is complete, buyers and sellers can’t share or ask for direct contact information, from names and phone numbers to social media IDs and website addresses. Sellers also can’t “Use contact information obtained through an eBay transaction to offer to buy or sell an item outside of eBay.” The fee policy bans “Linking or promoting sites, items, or catalogs that can be used to order items outside of eBay.”
Etsy’s rule reads, “A transaction initiated on Etsy may not be completed off of Etsy.” Its examples include “Encouraging buyers to purchase an item in your Etsy shop through another venue” and “Using a QR code to direct users off of the Etsy platform.” TikTok Shop lists “Making offers to buy or sell products off of the TikTok Shop platform” and “Sharing personal contact details with the intent to process offline transactions” as diverting traffic. Its Customer Service Policy also bans “Sharing off-platform promotions (discounts, free shipping, wholesale prices).” The rest of TikTok’s chat rules, like keeping returns inside TikTok Shop, are in How TikTok Shop Turns Short Videos Into Orders.
What a Message to a Buyer Can Say
Messages to buyers are meant for the order and the buyer’s questions, and Amazon’s Communication Guidelines define “Permitted Messages as those communications necessary to complete an order or to respond to a customer service inquiry,” while ruling out “Marketing or promotional messaging, including coupons.” The list of prohibited content includes email addresses and “External links unless they are secure working links (https, not http) necessary for order completion or links to Amazon.”
Walmart’s Customer Care policy prohibits “Including marketing/promotional materials or links to any website other than Walmart.com” and “Unsolicited text messages, emails or telephone calls to customers, including for marketing communications.” It also bars “Initiating contact via phone or any other method outside of your Seller Center Inbox,” though a seller can help a customer who calls first.
eBay counts unsolicited commercial offers sent through eBay Messages as spam, along with “Invitations to join a mailing list that aren’t related to your eBay Store.” Etsy’s Seller Policy says messages may not be used for “Sending unsolicited advertising or promotions, requests for donations, or spam,” and TikTok Shop says it “prohibits unsolicited marketing or promotional messages.” Review requests have their own rules, covered in How Reviews and Seller Feedback Work, and Why They Can’t Be Bought.
What Goes in the Box
The rules follow the order into the box, where Walmart bars marketing materials, as What Happens to Inventory Between the Supplier and the Customer covers. Walmart’s Retailer Agreement also keeps marketing and outside links out of the emails a seller sends about an order, “except for links to shipping websites that permit the Customer to track shipment of their Order.” TikTok Shop’s packing rules say “Do not include unauthorized marketing or promotional materials, such as pamphlets.” Every store we run is set up with the owner’s business as its seller of record, so all of these rules apply to the owner’s own account.
Why the Marketplaces Draw the Line Here
The marketplaces give 3 reasons, and the first is buyer protection. eBay says “Transactions conducted outside of eBay are not eligible for eBay protection programs and the eBay Money Back Guarantee.” Etsy says its Purchase Protection program and case system “aren’t available for transactions that take place off of Etsy.” Fraud is the second, with eBay calling offers to deal outside its site “a potential fraud risk for both buyers and sellers” and Amazon saying its messaging rules are “meant to protect buyers from fraud and abuse.”
Fees are the third, since a sale moved somewhere else skips the marketplace’s cut. eBay’s policy says “Avoiding eBay fees is not allowed, whether intentional or not.” Sellers still owe eBay’s fees on a sale that used eBay’s services even when the terms or the payment get settled outside eBay. eBay can even charge its final value fee on an item that never sold on eBay when the seller offered or asked for contact details to sell it elsewhere.
What’s at Stake for the Account
The penalties range from 1 listing up to the whole account, and eBay’s list goes from removing a listing and a warning to restricted activity and account suspension. TikTok Shop’s enforcement can include “Restricting access to TikTok Shop Chat” and “Shop deactivation,” and its fraud prevention rules add deductions from the Account Health Rating. Amazon can limit a seller’s messages or suspend “selling privileges in Amazon stores,” and Walmart and Etsy both name suspension or termination. What Happens When a Marketplace Suspends a Store walks through how those steps work.
A customer list an owner built on their own is treated differently, at least on Walmart. Its agreement says it “does not prevent you from using information you gathered independent of the Marketplace Program,” as long as the seller doesn’t target people for being Walmart.com users. The marketplace’s buyers stay with the marketplace, and the account holder answers for anything sent to them, as Who Should Own the Store Accounts When Someone Else Runs Them explains. Selling on Marketplaces vs Selling on Your Own Website covers what changes when a business sells to its customers on its own site.
Read Next
The marketplaces do give sellers their own ways to bring shoppers back, like sales and coupons, and each one splits the cost of a discount differently: Sales Events and Coupons, and Who Pays for the Discount.
Go to Post 56 →

